Comparison
Satchels in the test: Scout backpack comes last
In the satchel test, all five models performed well at Imtest. These include top brands such as Ergoback and Scout.
© romrodinka / Getty Images
As soon as school enrollment is in sight, many children are already looking forward to their big day. Especially the choice of the first own school bag causes a lot of excitement – also with the parents. In addition to the pencil case, colorful folders and a new lunch box, a stylish satchel is simply part of the basic inventory. But parents think much further: Which backpack is ergonomic? What is his maximum weight? questions upon questions.
The consumer portal Imtest has now tested five school satchels for primary school children and came up with a surprising result: the school satchel from Scout, the brand of many 2000 kids, came in last place. Here we show who is the winner in the satchel test and who sees Stiftung Warentest at the top.
Satchels put to the test: This knapsack beats Scout’s top sellers
“Wow, the children’s satchels are heavy!” Decades ago, our parents complained about the burden on our backs. Today it is similar: folders, books and pencil cases belong in the satchel despite digitization. But which backpack collapses under the load of books? Imtest has found a school bag winner among five models in the practical test: the school backpack from Ergobag.
The testers noticed the great variety of designs in this model: the satchel is available in over 29 looks. Quite apart from that, the satchel convinces in terms of ergonomics in the test. It sits in the middle of the back, and a drinking bottle and lunch box can be easily stowed away in waterproof outer compartments.
So that everything stays in place, children can lash their books and folders thanks to the drawstring. The backpack closes magnetically, but according to the test experts, the closure occasionally opens in the event of a fall. That’s manageable, because everything else is stuck in the satchel. A handful of reflectors distributed over the satchel ensure safety. Despite a rather high weight of 1,400 grams (without contents), Ergobag wins with an overall rating of 1.7.
- designs: over 29 (+ plugs)
- Weight: 1.4 kilograms
- size adjustment: stepless
- Accesories: Sports backpack, 5 Kletties, DIN A4 notebook box, pencil case, pencil case
- Price: from 239.99 euros
Fun fact: Not only Imtest chooses Ergobag as the test winner. In 2019, the brand won in the large satchel check by Stiftung Warentest. At that time, the test magazine compared 22 satchels with each other. The “Cubo Neo Illumibär” turned out to be the winner, but it is no longer on the market. The model is identical in construction to the Imtest winner 2023. It scored plus points thanks to its great visibility, top wearing comfort and the infinitely adjustable back part.
Scout takes last place in the test: Still a top result!
In the school satchel test by Imtest, it quickly becomes apparent that no product is completely negative. With the worst grade (2.2), the best-known brand in the race ended up in fifth and last place. The Scout Backpack”genius” gets a few deductions in the B grade, since its accessories are smaller than those of its competitors. Instead of an outside pocket for a drinking bottle, a small space behind a zipper has to suffice.
Everything else, such as ergonomics, handling, safety, water resistance etc., convinced the testers. With a capacity of 19 liters, the satchel is the model with the least storage space for materials in the test. However, the difference is minimal. In return, the motley design inspires, which immediately catches the eye on the road thanks to the striking neon colors and is clearly recognizable even in the dark. The average price is 215 euros.
Amazon’s cheap alternative: school bag set from Belmil
When looking for a suitable school bag for primary school children, the high purchase price immediately catches the eye. The satchels in the test all cost over 200 euros. This is just too much for some families, even if all models are durable and ideally have more than four years of daily use.
Alternatively, there is the Amazon bestseller from Belmil for about 120 euros. The inexpensive alternative to the test models is available in over 40 designs. The set includes a pencil case, a gym bag and a beautifully designed pencil case. The satchel with chest strap is peppered with reflectors – the item is lightweight (990 grams). This makes the satchel ideal for petite children. At Amazon there is an overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars for an attractive price-performance ratio.
- designs: over 40
- Weight: approx. 990 grams
- size adjustment: two steps
- Accesories: sports bag, pencil case, pencil case#
Satchels in the test: brands like Ergobag and Scount are all “good”
The satchel test at Imtest showed one thing above all: all tested models were good. Here the decision stands and falls primarily with the design. Children and parents can let off steam here. In the best-case scenario, children will try out the satchels to find the perfect model for their stature and everyday life. It doesn’t always have to be premium brands, there can also be cheap alternatives.
Note: This article first appeared on rtl.de
You might also be interested in:
This article contains so-called affiliate links. Further information are available here.