Understanding the Pension System Deficit: Is it 6.1 or 55 Billion Euros?

Discussions on the pension deficit intensify as Prime Minister François Bayrou seeks consensus among unions and employers to address a reported €55 billion gap in the pension system. While the government claims substantial deficits, labor unions argue that recent data suggests a surplus for 2023. Economist Vincent Touzé highlights differing accounting methods between public and private sector pensions. The Court of Auditors will assess the pension scheme’s balance, with findings expected by February 19.

Understanding the Pension Deficit Debate

The ongoing discussions surrounding the pension deficit have sparked significant debate among political leaders, particularly in light of the reforms passed in 2023. Prime Minister François Bayrou has reignited conversations about pension reform, bringing various social partners together for a three-month social conference aimed at revising the current legislation. However, all stakeholders must adhere to one crucial principle: avoid exacerbating the public finances deficit.

Prime Minister Bayrou emphasizes the necessity for a consensus between unions and employers that does not contribute to the pension system’s existing deficit. The foundation of this debate involves the initial figures presented. In his policy address, Bayrou highlighted an annual gap of €55 billion that the state must address.

The Discrepancy in Deficit Estimates

During a session at the National Assembly, Bayrou elaborated, stating, “Our pension system disburses approximately €380 billion in pensions annually, while contributions from employers and employees total around €325 billion. This leaves a deficit of €55 billion, which is covered by public authority budgets, amounting to €40 to €45 billion from the state alone. Unfortunately, we currently have no funds to cover this shortfall, resulting in national debt.”

However, labor unions contest this perspective, claiming that the actual deficit is significantly lower. They reference the latest report from the Pension Orientation Council (COR), released in June 2024, which indicated a surplus of €3.8 billion in 2023, followed by a projected deficit of €6.1 billion in 2024—eight times less than Bayrou’s estimate.

Economist Vincent Touzé from the French Observatory for Economic Conjunctures (OFCE) contributes to the dialogue, asserting that the discrepancies stem from different accounting methods. He explains, “The pension system for civil servants is an employer-funded scheme tied to their employment contracts, obligating the state to fulfill these pension commitments without prior funding. In contrast, private sector companies are required to provision these commitments at the time they are made.”

Bayrou’s calculations encompass total state contributions, including historical unprovisioned commitments. According to Touzé, “The private sector’s pension scheme has a contribution rate of 28%, whereas the state bears an expenditure rate of 85%. Bayrou believes this 57-point difference represents the additional funding required to balance the scheme, which he perceives as an overspending. If the contribution rate remained constant, the deficit could indeed reach €55 billion.”

However, it is imperative to note that a substantial portion of this figure pertains to contractual commitments. Touzé clarifies, “The state is merely fulfilling its obligations to retired civil servants. These commitments are legally binding, and pension payments are guaranteed by the state, which ensures the necessary funds are available.” He argues that while pensions impose significant costs on public finances, labeling the entire amount as a scheme deficit—when a considerable part relates to civil servant pensions—raises questions about the accuracy of the assessment.

The Court of Auditors has been tasked by the Prime Minister to conduct a thorough evaluation of the pension scheme’s balance, with a report anticipated by February 19. This analysis may provide clearer insights into the true financial standing of the pension system.

If you have inquiries or wish to share information that may be misleading, please reach out to us at [email protected]. You can also connect with our team on X at @verif_TF1LCI.

Related Articles