The Lord of the Rings: Exploring Elrond’s Decision Not to Force Isildur into Mount Doom with the Ring

Elrond, a powerful Elf in Middle-earth, played by Hugo Weaving and Robert Aramayo, has significantly influenced history since the First Age. After the Battle of the Last Alliance, he guides Isildur to destroy the One Ring but hesitates, fearing its corrupting power. Understanding the Ring’s seductive nature, Elrond refrains from seizing it, knowing that even he could succumb to its influence. As fans anticipate the finale of ‘The Rings of Power,’ more insights into Elrond’s choices may emerge.

Elrond: The Powerful Elf of Middle-earth

Elrond, portrayed by Hugo Weaving in the iconic ‘The Lord of the Rings’ films and Robert Aramayo in Amazon’s ‘The Rings of Power,’ stands as one of the most formidable beings in the vast universe of Middle-earth. Having traversed this realm since the First Age, Elrond has had the opportunity to shape history on several occasions. At one pivotal moment, he even had the chance to obliterate the One Ring, a task that could have altered the fate of all.

The Dilemma of the One Ring

Following the climactic Battle of the Last Alliance, where both Gil-galad, Elrond’s king, and Sauron fall, Elrond guides Isildur (played by Harry Sinclair) to Mount Doom. He implores Isildur to cast the One Ring into the flames, thereby vanquishing Sauron once and for all. However, Isildur, seduced by the Ring’s power, chooses to keep it, leaving Elrond in a state of helplessness.

This raises a compelling question: why does such a mighty Elf, fully aware of the malevolent influence of the Ring, refrain from taking action? Elrond could have easily defeated Isildur and destroyed the Ring himself. Yet, the fear of the Ring’s corrupting power holds him back. J.R.R. Tolkien illustrates that the Ring amplifies the abilities of its bearer, which poses a significant threat to those who are already powerful.

Even the great Gandalf (Ian McKellen) refuses to touch the Ring when it is offered to him by Frodo, and Elrond shares this apprehension. The Elf realizes that if he were to take the Ring from Isildur, he might not possess the strength needed to destroy it, potentially becoming a greater threat than Isildur himself. His desire to use the Ring for good could lead him down a dark path.

While Sam (Sean Astin) can carry Frodo (Elijah Wood) in ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King’ without being influenced by the Ring, the same cannot be said for Elrond. The reason Frodo is tasked with bringing the Ring to Mount Doom is that Hobbits, unlike Elves and other beings, are less susceptible to its allure. Though Sam may be under the Ring’s influence to a degree, it is minimal compared to what Elrond would face.

In the upcoming finale of ‘The Rings of Power,’ we may witness the moment when Elrond urges Isildur to destroy the Ring, potentially shedding more light on his inaction. Fans can stream the entire ‘The Lord of the Rings’ trilogy on Amazon Prime Video, along with the prequel series ‘The Rings of Power,’ as work continues on Season 3 of this beloved saga.

Related Articles