Germany’s conservative Union parties and the Social Democrats have formed a surprising debt-financed initiative for defense and infrastructure amid new government talks. This plan includes exempting defense spending from the debt brake and establishing a 500 billion euro infrastructure fund. However, the agreement raises concerns about future fiscal responsibility and potential inflation, as it may lead to increased debt and interest costs, while also lacking clear commitments for future defense financing.
A Surprising Shift in German Financial Policy
In an unexpected turn of events, Germany’s conservative Union parties, CDU and CSU, along with the Social Democrats (SPD), have come together to establish a debt-financed defense and infrastructure initiative. This agreement, reached amid ongoing talks for forming a new government, has caught many observers off guard, particularly in light of recent geopolitical tensions. The financial package is poised to receive approval from the outgoing Bundestag next week.
Key Components of the Debt-Financed Package
The Union and SPD are working to secure a two-thirds majority in the old Bundestag for necessary amendments to the Basic Law, relying on support from either the Greens or the FDP. However, the political landscape has shifted since the newly elected Bundestag was formed ten days ago, with the AfD and the Left Party holding a blocking minority that could complicate matters.
On Tuesday evening, CDU leader Friedrich Merz outlined the package, which comprises four major elements. Firstly, any defense expenditure exceeding 1% of Germany’s GDP—approximately 44 billion euros annually—will be exempt from the debt brake, allowing future financing through debt. Secondly, the Union and SPD plan to establish a substantial “special fund” of 500 billion euros dedicated to infrastructure improvements over the next decade, which will also be excluded from the debt brake calculations. Thirdly, provisions will be made for federal states to incur minor new debts in the future. Lastly, an expert commission will be tasked with proposing long-term reforms to the debt brake during the legislative period.
This initiative marks a significant departure from Germany’s traditional financial policy. The existing debt brake, which has maintained strict borrowing limits and moderate debt levels, will largely lose its effectiveness.
As Europe, and particularly Germany, prepares to bolster its defense capabilities and support Ukraine independent of the US, higher defense spending becomes a pressing necessity. Typically, military financing should come from ongoing revenues to prevent an escalating debt burden. However, in light of urgent circumstances, a temporary special fund could be justified to allow for essential budget reallocations.
Despite this, the agreement between the SPD and the Union lacks a definitive commitment regarding future defense spending. It is anticipated that a significant portion will be financed through debt, which contradicts the need for fiscal responsibility.
The second contentious issue is the infrastructure fund. While it is undeniable that infrastructure such as railways, bridges, and schools have suffered from neglect over the years, the urgency of addressing these issues is not a new development linked to recent events. These improvements should be managed through regular budget allocations over an extended period.
In the short term, if this debt strategy is implemented, it could lead to increased interest costs for the state budget and taxpayers. Infusing substantial funds into the economy also carries the risk of inflation, especially since current construction capacities may not meet the heightened demand, resulting in rising prices.
Moreover, with this preliminary agreement, the Union and SPD may inadvertently eliminate the incentive to prioritize state budget allocations in the upcoming legislative period, potentially perpetuating excessive social spending and subsidies. This approach could unduly burden future generations with increased debt, contradicting Merz’s campaign promises.
For more insights, follow Berlin economic correspondent René Höltschi on platforms like X and LinkedIn.